Moving Beyond Charity Overheads

First published on Why Philanthropy Matters in March 2024. Updated October 2026.

Judging a charity by how little it spends on overheads tells you almost nothing about how much good it does. A low overhead figure can even be a warning sign: it often means a charity isn’t investing in the people, systems and ideas it needs to deliver lasting change. To understand a charity’s real value, look at its outcomes, not its costs.

Dan Pallotta’s 2024 film Uncharitable calls for a paradigm shift in the way we think about charity, aiming to unleash the true potential of non-profits and philanthropy to change the world.

It’s not a new idea. The film builds on one of the most watched TED talks, in which Pallotta set out the deeply damaging impact of what he calls the overhead myth.

To most people in the non-profit world, the subject is old news. Many have sore heads from banging them against the proverbial brick wall. Yet more than a decade after that talk, Pallotta and many others are still fighting to overcome the same deeply ingrained misconceptions. At Raise Your Hands, helping to shift the dial is part of our mission.

So why do we still pay such a high price for low overheads?

What is the overhead myth, and why is it so damaging?

At the heart of the problem is something completely understandable: donors want their money spent effectively. We all want confidence that our money is making a difference and isn’t being wasted.

The problem comes when donors use overhead costs as a measure of efficiency. Think “90p in every pound goes to frontline work”. Donors want to know how much of their donation goes to programme work, and the higher the number, the better.

In the commercial sector, the focus would be on outputs. As an investor, you’d look at how many customers a company has, how satisfied they are and the quality of its products. Those factors define the return on investment, not how much the company spends on office space or advertising.

It should be the same in the charity sector. Instead of costs, we should focus on outcomes: the amount and quality of positive change being made in the world.

In the for-profit world, it’s understood that to run effectively and grow, a company must spend a proportion of its revenue on overheads and on reinvesting in the business. That proportion varies widely from sector to sector, and is tested and optimised to generate the most output and growth. [The original gave figures of around 20% for retail and up to 50% for services, but didn’t cite a source, so I’ve left them out. Add them back with a source if you have one.]

As an investor, you wouldn’t walk into the shareholder meeting of a highly successful company and start quibbling about the cost of the office chairs, insisting costs should be as close to zero as possible. Yet that’s exactly what happens in the non-profit world.

The knock-on effects

It would be ironic if it weren’t so damaging: the focus on overheads, meant to limit inefficiency, makes the charity sector less effective and stifles innovation.

It creates a cycle with many negative effects. Donors steer towards organisations with the “leanest” margins. Charity leaders feel the pressure to meet that demand, so they cut budgets for innovation, rely on stale fundraising formulas, underinvest in staff and focus on the short term. They present their accounts to look as lean as possible, which reinforces the myth and makes things harder for the whole sector.

In Uncharitable, Pallotta describes non-profits generating huge returns on their fundraising investment, only to be brought to their knees by questions over whether £1 that generated £8 should have been spent on frontline work instead.

Why “overheads” is a meaningless metric

Look closely at overheads as a metric and it quickly proves so flawed that it’s almost meaningless for comparing charities.

  • Different charities work in very different ways. One might rely on volunteers and need no fixed office. Another might need premises, medically trained professionals and expensive equipment. Their fixed costs are very different, and neither has any bearing on their impact.
  • Accounting can move the numbers. It’s entirely within the rules to reclassify some overhead costs as programme costs. But doing so takes more specialist accountancy work, which costs more time and money: the opposite of efficient.
  • One year is a snapshot. These figures come from annual accounts. When a charity’s financial year ends can make a big difference, especially for charities that rely on “lumpy” donations. A single year never gives an accurate picture of an organisation’s finances.

So where does that leave us?

Ultimately, donors need to look at an organisation’s impact in a meaningful way: its output, to use commercial-sector language.

That isn’t easy. Comparing one charity’s work with another’s is like comparing apples and pears. At Raise Your Hands, we support 16 small charities working with children and young people. Dandelion Time [link: /charities/dandelion-time/] offers therapy on a working farm for children who have experienced severe trauma and abuse. Chiva [link: /charities/chiva/] supports children and young people across the UK living with HIV, and the stigma that can come with it.

It’s virtually impossible to put a single number on the difference these charities make to young lives, let alone compare them.

Purely quantitative approaches quickly narrow giving down to the few causes where impact is easy to measure, such as mosquito nets that prevent malaria and save lives. But that ignores most causes, where impact is more nuanced.

Then there’s the work charities do to tackle wider, systemic problems, such as research or campaigning to change policy. The long-term ripples of that impact can be extremely hard to attribute.

A true analysis of effectiveness

As with any investment, an informed decision means looking at every level of an organisation.

Our due diligence at Raise Your Hands looks at how well programmes are designed, the monitoring and evaluation in place, the strength and leadership of the management team, and whether funding is sustainable and well managed. And yes, costs too. [Link: How we choose our charities]

The judgement is always qualitative as well as quantitative, and to some extent subjective as well as objective. Along with your own preferences about which causes to support, making that call takes time and knowledge of the sector.

At Raise Your Hands, we do much of that heavy lifting for our supporters, both individuals and companies. Our in-depth knowledge of small charities puts us in a strong position to make those judgement calls.

What can individual philanthropists do?

  • Do your homework. As you would with a commercial investment, take time to read a charity’s impact report, strategy, annual report and accounts.
  • Ask the right questions. How do you track your impact? What’s your culture of innovation?
  • Visit. Go and see the charity in action, meet staff and leaders, and see the change for yourself, remembering that their time is precious too.

In the end, impact comes down to change in the world: people’s (and animals’) lives improved for the better. That takes not just logic but what Dan Pallotta calls “generosity of thought”.

To recap…

What is the overhead myth?
The mistaken belief that the less a charity spends on running costs (such as staff, systems and fundraising), the better it is. In reality, investing in those things is often what makes a charity effective.

What’s a better way to judge a charity?
Look at its outcomes: the difference it makes for the people it serves. Also look at how well its programmes are designed, how it measures impact, the quality of its leadership and whether its finances are sustainable.

At Raise Your Hands, we never judge a charity by its overheads. We look at the whole picture, so every small charity on our platform is one you can back with confidence.

Similar Posts